Let’s Chill is apparently a Yelp accolade magnet, holding its No. 2 ranking ever since the 2023 edition of Yelp’s “Top 100 U.S. Ice Cream Shops.” (No ranking took place in 2024.) In May, the Bragas also earned a spot on Yelp’s “Top 100 Local Businesses 2025” national ranking.

Although frozen custard is synonymous with Wisconsin, the state's ice cream is top-tier, too. In celebration of National Ice Cream Day on July 20, Yelp released its list of the top 100 ice cream shops across the nation — and a Madison shop ranked 55th.

Yelp named Phoenix-based Novel Ice Cream the best ice cream shop in the country as it declared a list of Top 100 Ice Cream Shops 2025.